Plus & Sumlock Mechanical Calculators
All of the mechanical calculators manufactured by Bell Punch were key-driven machines of the 'Comptometer' type.
Introduction to the 'Comptometer' type calculator:
The Comptometer was invented by the American Dorr Eugene Felt and was patented in 1887. Manufactured by the Felt & Tarrant Manufacturing Company of Chicago, the Comptometer was the first truly practical and commercially successful adding machine. They proved very successful and were developed and manufactured by Felt & Tarrant and rival companies in large numbers into the early 1970s.
A Model J, British Sterling currency (£sd), Comptometer. Manufactured in the USA by the Felt & Tarrant Manufacturing Co, in the 1920s-1930s period.
'Comptometer' eventually became to be used as a generic name for calculators of this type from other manufacturers, though strictly this is wrong. However, to complicate matters, in 1957 the Felt and Tarrant Manufacturing Company changed its name to Comptometer Corporation. Then in 1960 Comptometer Corporation sold its UK. operation, including the right to the Comptometer name in Britain, to Control Systems Ltd., the parent of Bell Punch, which merged it with its own company to form Sumlock-Comptometer. Comptometer Corporation then contracted with Control Systems to have all its machines made by Bell Punch in England and shipped back to the U.S.A. This resulted in all Comptometer production ceasing in Chicago in 1961, and in machines from Sumlock being marked with the Comptometer name.
The Comptometer was the first successful key driven adding and calculating machine. "Key driven" means that just pressing the keys adds the numbers entered to the total - no other action is required - so it is very quick for adding long lists of numbers. The basic function of the Comptometer is addition. There is a column of keys (in general 1-9) for each decade. When a key is pressed, that number is added to that decade, with carry to the next higher decade, if applicable. Operating the handle clears the total to zero.
Comptometers are very fast in operation when adding up lists, such as required in accounting. Operators were specially trained to make use of the full keyboard and enter each number by pressing all the digits in one go using
all fingers, as necessary, at once. In other words all the digits were entered in parallel, the mechanism being able to cope with this.
In contrast a modern electronic calculator only has 10 digit keys so the digits of each number have to be entered one at a time, serially, which is slower.
Comptometers were widely used into the late 1970s and were ousted by advances in the use of computers for accounting rather than the development of electronic calculators. People trained in the proper and swift use of Comptometers often kept using them into later years for adding up lists since they are quicker than a standard ten-key electronic calculator.
Although these machines were very successful and thousands were sold, only a few companies manufactured the 'Comptometer' type of calculator. The main manufacturers were Felt & Tarrant (later Victor Comptometer) and Burroughs in the U.S.A., and Bell Punch in Britain.
There are excellent photographs and descriptions of the Plus Adder mechanism at John Wolff's Web Museum site. These are accessed from the Comptometers and Key-Driven Calculators section on that site.
Bell Punch Mechanical Calculators
The Bell Punch company did not manufacture any calculators until the 1930s when in 1936 the parent company, Control Systems, acquired the rights to the adding machines of the Comptometer type manufactured by Petters, Limited, of Yeovil, England and sold under the name 'Petometer'.
Due in part to the use of the old £sd Sterling currency and imperial units of measurement in Britain and the British Commonwealth, Bell Punch manufactured a greater variety of 'Comptometer' type calculators than any other company.
The early Petter based models were introduced by Bell Punch in about 1937 under the name 'Plus Adder'.
These are all abbreviated keyboard models, that is they only have keys 1 to 5 in any column. To add a number higher than 5 then the operator has to press first one key and then another in that column which add up to the required number.
An early Plus Adder, with 'abbreviated' keyboard (only having numbers up to 5 in each column).
In 1940 a larger, full keyboard (with numbers 1 to 9 in each column), machine under the name 'Sumlock" was added to the range, and a separate company, London Computator Corporation, Limited, was incorporated to deal more efficiently with the sales side of the calculators.
An early Sumlock machine, distributed by London Computator Corporation.
In 1950 the name of London Computator Ltd. was changed to Sumlock Limited, and this in turn became Sumlock Comptometer Limited in 1961 when the British operation of Comptometer Corporation was merged.
The magazine of Control Systems Ltd. for Winter 1959 lists the following dates of introduction of Bell Punch mechanical calculators:
The last new models of Bell Punch mechanical calculators, the 993 series, were introduced in 1964. Plus models were manufactured by Sumlock Anita Electronics into the 1970s.
Bell Punch were the world's largest producer of 'abbreviated' 'Comptometer'-type calculators with their 'Plus' range. Having columns with keys only up 5, these were cheaper, smaller, and lighter than full-keyboard machines and with little or no speed penalty.
The 'Plus' machines are designed purely for adding operations, while the 'Sumlock' and 'Comptometer' models have keys marked also with the nines-complement numbers and have 'prevent carry over' buttons for use with subtraction operations. For details of performing calculations on a Sumlock Comptometer see the article on the sister site to this.
Later Model numbering scheme - The Sumlock and later Plus model numbers are of the form XYY/Z, where:
X is the number of rows of keys, and YY is the number of columns of keys .
Z is one or more suffix letters to give the type of calculator.
From observation, the following is a list of some, mainly suffix, designations of the types of Plus and Sumlock machine:
Converted machines. When Britain and the Commonwealth changed from the old Sterling £sd currency to decimal currency the Sterling currency machines could still be used by ignoring the shillings and pennies columns.
However, on machines with few columns to start with, such as the 509/S, this does not leave many useful columns. It appears that to overcome this it was common to modify Sterling currency machines by replacing the shillings and pennies columns with decimal columns, since such modified machines are sometimes seen.
This involves drilling extra holes in the top and fitting the decimal keys and mechanism from another machine. Such machines appear to be decimal, may have some blanked off key holes, have a serial number including /S, and usually still have the yellow lines on the accumulator register which separated the £sd sections. This may not have been an official modification since examples seen are often somewhat crude. For an example see the Plus Adder D (converted).
The Plus machines changed to a more angular design in early 1958.
For Plusograph see the Calculators made by others section.
Development of the Plus Adder:
The "Petometer" - the forerunner to the "Plus Adder". Bell Punch bought the design and rights of this machine in 1936 from Petters of Yeovil. It was the basis for the development of the "Plus Adder".
Small "Plus Adder" with Bakelite casing. The mechanism operates on the downward strokes of the keys, but there is no protection on incomplete strokes (not pressing the key far enough) which can lead to false entries. About 1936-
Large "Plus Adder" with thin sheet metal casing, again with the mechanism operating on the downward strokes of the keys.
Was the sheet metal casing a war-time economy measure, releasing Bakelite for more important uses, or was it a quick way to meet demand for a 12-column machine without going to the expense of making the tooling for the larger bakelite moulding? If you have any information about this please let me know.
Improvements to the mechanism
The mechanism of the Plus and Sumlock machines was steadily developed. The most significant improvements were:
Later, "London Computator Corporation", version with die-cast metal casing with black plastic handles.
The mechanism from this model onwards is more advanced, operating on the return stroke of the keys as described above. About 1940-
Die-cast metal casing version produced in the 1950s, with painted steel strips between the key stems.
More angular, single-piece die-cast metal casing version, introduced in 1958. The cylindrical keys protrude from circular holes in the casing.
Beige paint colour appears to have been used from the mid 1960s.
In the early 1940's Bell Punch introduced a full-keyboard machine under the Sumlock name which was sold by their London Computator Corporation marketing company. The name refers to the interlocking of the mechanism to prevent
incomplete key strokes (the key does not return, and no other key in the same column can be depressed, until it is pressed far enough).
In 1950 the name of the marketing company was changed to Sumlock Ltd.
Sales brochure for Sumlock machines (pdf format), from 1947.
London Computator Corporation 'Sumlock' full-keyboard machine. 1940s.
A Sumlock Ltd. full-keyboard machine. Late 1940s-
In mid-1960 Control Systems Ltd. (the parent of Bell Punch) acquired the English operation of Comptometer Corporation (previously the Felt & Tarrant Manufacturing Company) of Chicago, U.S.A., including the trademark and the right to the 'Comptometer' name in England, and then signed a contract with Control Systems to have all their machines manufactured in England. Sumlock machines then appeared under the Comptometer label.
A Sumlock 'Comptometer'.
Below is a demonstration model of the later, more complicated, interlocked mechanism. To minimise incomplete key strokes the key does not move the gear wheels on the downwards stroke, but lightly
triggers the mechanism to move the gears on the spring-driven return stroke.
Also there is interlocking to prevent inadvertent pressing of two keys in the same column. Once a key is depressed by a small amount all of the other keys in the same column are locked and cannot be depressed.
Bell Punch produced these demonstration models. They could be used to show customers how the interlocking mechanism worked, so making the machines less liable to operator error.
Side view of the mechanism.
Progressively to the back of the mechanism (that is to the right) the keys push further down the lever with the sector gear on its left end. When the key is released the lever moves forwards, the sector gear engages with a gear at the front and move the number drum on accordingly.
Keys are interlocked and do not return unless they are pressed fully down. No other key in the column can be pressed until all keys in the column are back fully upwards.
The accumulator drum and the carry mechanism.
There are excellent photographs and descriptions of the later Plus Adder mechanism at John Wolff's Web Museum site. These are accessed from the Comptometers and Key-Driven Calculators section on that site.
Plus & Sumlock Mechanical Calculators
Text & photographs copyright © 2002 - 2022 Nigel Tout, except where noted otherwise.